The 10 Best Menthol Aftershave 2022

Last Update:

Selecting the Best Menthol Aftershave becomes a daunting task if you do not have notes on what you want in it. While searching on the internet, you come across different types and features. People buy based on their requirements and budget.

So, before making a decision, you need to know what functionality you desire to get. Figuring out what attributes you want makes the selection process easier
Now, what features to look for and how to make a checklist of things you want. To clear up your tangled mind, we have worked on a buying guide.

Best Menthol Aftershave
As Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. The price remains the same for you.

Comparison Table – Best Menthol Aftershave

In this list, you will see the top 12 Best Menthol Aftershave selected by our expert team. All of them are available on Amazon during the research time. At the end of this article, you will also get a comprehensive buyer’s guide that will help you further.

1Gabel's Lime Aftershave with Menthol (Limited Edition) 10 fl. oz9.8View on Amazon
2Proraso After Shave Lotion for Men9.4View on Amazon
3Gabel's Aftershave / Astringent - Eucalyptus with Menthol (Up A Notch 70%) 8oz9.4View on Amazon
4Proraso After Shave Balm for Men9.2View on Amazon
5Duke Cannon Supply Co. - Ice Cold Cooling Effect After-Shave Balm9.2View on Amazon
6Lucky Tiger After Shave Cream8.8View on Amazon
7Suavecito Menthol After Shave 8 oz8.6View on Amazon
8Badger - After-Shave Face Oil8.4View on Amazon
9Cryogen - Ultra High Menthol Aftershave Splash By Chiseled Face Groomatorium - Handmade8.2View on Amazon
10Hurley Men's Aftershave - Cooling Menthol Post Shave Balm8.2View on Amazon

Table Of Content:

1. Gabel’s Lime Aftershave with Menthol (Limited Edition) 10 fl. oz

  • Gabel’s Lime Aftershave with Menthol (Limited Edition) 10 fl. oz
  • Cooling, Soothing, Refreshing.
  • Limited Edition bottle. Barber’s classics
  • Made from USA grain based ethanol alcohol. Cruelty Free. Vegan.
  • This item is Non returnable

2. Proraso After Shave Lotion for Men

  • Anti-irritation, for sensitive skin
  • Menthol refreshes and revitalizes
  • No parabens; No silicons; No mineral oils; No artificial colors

3. Gabel’s Aftershave / Astringent – Eucalyptus with Menthol (Up A Notch 70%) 8oz

  • Up A Notch To 70% Alcohol. Made with grain based Ethanol
  • Refreshing Astringent and Aftershave. Vintage barber shop scent.
  • Cooling and Soothing to ease the razor bumps.
  • Eucalyptus Oil, Menthol and Aloe Vera, Glycerin enriched.
  • Men Grooming essential shaving care.

4. Proraso After Shave Balm for Men

  • Alcohol-free, non-greasy formula soothes and provides immediate relief after shaving.
  • Combines hydrating properties of a balm with calming and soothing benefits of a cream.
  • Enriched with Eucalyptus Oil to purify skin and reduce inflammation.
  • Enriched with Menthol to revitalize, tone, cool and refresh.
  • Cruelty free, over 95% natural and contains no silicones, mineral oils, SLS or parabens

5. Duke Cannon Supply Co. – Ice Cold Cooling Effect After-Shave Balm

  • TWO PACK OF BOTTLES – With two 6 oz.
  • SUPERIOR INGREDIENTS – A mixture of aloe, shea butter, baobab oil, and allantoin provide hydration while minimizing irritation from razor burn.
  • MASCULINE SCENT – Great for all skin types, bergamot and sandalwood fragrance leaves a man smelling fresh and clean.
  • UNIQUE COOLING EFFECT – Premium formulation of menthol, tea tree, and Tamanu oil helps to repair and close pores almost instantaneously.
  • MADE IN AMERICA – Made in the USA, a portion of proceeds benefits U.

6. Lucky Tiger After Shave Cream

  • Country of origin is United States
  • Item Package Length: 8.636cm
  • Item Package Width: 8.89cm
  • Item Package Height: 10.16cm

7. Suavecito Menthol After Shave 8 oz

  • Soothing aftershave
  • Prevents razor irratation
  • Made 100% in the U.S.A.

8. Badger – After-Shave Face Oil

  • MOISTURIZING AFTERSHAVE – This moisturizing after shave oil has the uplifting aroma of Bergamot, with cooling Menthol and the skin soothing properties of Rosehip and Pomegranate.
  • SUNFLOWER & BAOBAB – Light Organic Sunflower and Baobab Oils restore your skin’s moisture and balance without leaving an oily feel.
  • VITAMINS & ANTIOXIDANTS – Nourish your skin after shaving with natural vitamins A, D, E, & F, essential fatty acids, and powerful antioxidants.
  • BOTANICAL INGREDIENTS – Free-of artificial ingredients, fragrances, dyes, parabens, GMOs, synthetic chemicals, or harsh ingredients.
  • CERTIFIED ORGANIC INGREDEINTS – Badger After-Shave Oil uses USDA Certified Organic ingredients and is petrolatum-free.

9. Cryogen – Ultra High Menthol Aftershave Splash By Chiseled Face Groomatorium – Handmade

  • Handmade in small batches
  • Contains Aloe Vera, Witch Hazel, Calendula, Seaweed, and Vitamin B12 Pro to sooth, heal, and nourish skin.
  • No artificial colors, parabens, or preservatives
  • Ultra High Menthol Content
  • Coldest aftershave you can imagine!

10. Hurley Men’s Aftershave – Cooling Menthol Post Shave Balm

  • Soothing and Moisturizing: This lightweight and fast-absorbing aftershave balm cools skin and soothes razor burn.
  • Formula: Infused with Castor, Eucalyptus Oil, and Menthol, this men’s post shave balm leaves skin feeling soft and moisturized.
  • Free From: High quality skin moisturizer is cruelty-free and paraben-free
  • Ideal After Shave Balm: For Teenagers and Men of any age with any skin type, especially men with sensitive skin prone to post shave irritation and dryness.
  • How to Use: After shaving, massage a small amount of Hurley Post Shave Balm into the face and neck until completely absorbed.

How to Choose The Best Menthol Aftershave?

Out of all the Menthol Aftershave in the market, you need to know which one is right for you. For that, you need to see if it solves your problem, lies within your budget, convenience, and reliability. Let’s touch on some important factors that you cannot ignore to achieve the desired performance.


Will the Menthol Aftershave function as advertised? It will only be reliable if it functions the same way every time you use it. To know about reliability, you can check the reviews of those who have had the Best Menthol Aftershave for a long time. Also, purchasing from trusted brands will keep you satisfied with the maintained quality.


In the world of social media, people regularly keep you posted about the brands they purchase from and their positive experiences. Once an opinion is formed about a brand, it gives customers satisfaction while buying. Picking a trusted brand reduces chaos and makes it easier to look for what you need.


Warranty offered on the product assures quality and saves you from manufacturing faults. If you receive a faulty product or missing accessories, you can contact the company to assist you free of cost within the mentioned period. You must read the terms and conditions of the warranty to avoid any misconceptions



The Menthol Aftershave must function the way you want it to tackle your need. It is only useful to you if it performs its task, and it is easy to use and safe. Also, it must be durable to withstand its function. You are paying for that main purpose so it must justify the price. Then, if you can spend more, you can go for additional features for your convenience.

Design and Shape

The product must be designed to cater to the customer's needs. A sleek design with easy operation and usage will be more comfortable than dealing with a complicated design. The product should be of high quality, functional, and attractive in design to trigger the customers to buy.

Best Prices

Models with different features come in different price ranges. More than one functionality will cost you more. So, you need to consider how much you can spend on the product. If you are short on budget, then you should go for the main features and if you can invest well then no problem remains. Best Menthol Aftershave are the ones that are cost-effective delivering desired performance.


Going through the buying guide, you would have made up your mind about the Menthol Aftershave you wished to get. Identify your need first before looking for a Menthol Aftershave. Knowing the features before the selection will help you differentiate between the models.

In this article, we have provided a detailed guide for the Best Menthol Aftershave. Go for reliability. Check the warranty and read the reviews to see what people say about the Menthol Aftershave. Make sure you read it carefully before making the final decision so the purchase does not leave you disappointed.

I hope this post gives you a happy shopping experience. You can share it with the ones looking for the same.

Leave a Comment